Skip to content
Discount & Bundles Galore! See Details. | FREE Domestic Shipping $70+
Discount & Bundles Galore! | FREE Domestic Shipping $70+
FAQ Services Affiliate

Stuffed Animals

Buy 2, Get 3rd for 10% OFF! Add 3 of any combination to your cart and the discount will automatically applied at checkout. This offer can be an unlimited number of times.
  • $9.95 - $9.95
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    $9.95

    Mini I Love NY Teddy Bears | I Love NY Gifts (5 Colors)

    Popular selection of cute I Love NY Teddy Bears coming 4 colors: White, Black, Pink, Purple. Make this the perfect I Love NY Gift for children &...

    View full details
    $9.95 - $9.95
    $9.95
    $9.95 - $9.95
    $9.95
  • $16.25 - $16.25
    $16.25
    $16.25 - $16.25
    $16.25

    Vintage I Love NY Teddy Bear Stuffed Toy | New York Teddy Bear (2 Colors)

    Cuddly and bright eyed Stuffed Animal teddy bear incorporating the I Love NY Logo Embroidered and stitched to the torso. Surface Washable soft plus...

    View full details
    $16.25 - $16.25
    $16.25
    $16.25 - $16.25
    $16.25
  • Save 33% Save %
    $39.99
    $39.99 - $39.99
    $39.99
    $26.95
    $26.95 - $26.95
    $26.95

    New York Police Department "NYPD" Souvenir Teddy Bear (12x7") | NYC Souvenir

    Cuddly and bright eyed Stuffed Animal NYPD Officer teddy nyc souvenir. Surface Washable soft plush fur and build. Comes fitted in a full Navy Blue ...

    View full details
    $39.99
    $39.99 - $39.99
    $39.99
    $26.95
    $26.95 - $26.95
    $26.95
    Save 33% Save %
  • Save up to 23% Save %
    $24.99 - $44.99
    $24.99 - $44.99
    $24.99
    $19.49 - $36.95
    $19.49 - $36.95
    $19.49

    Sloth Stuffed Animal I Love NY Gift | I Love NY Toy (3 Sizes)

    A high quality ultra plush, soft fur Sloth Stuffed animal embroidered with the official I Love NY logo central to the torso. This luxury I Love NY ...

    View full details
    $24.99 - $44.99
    $24.99 - $44.99
    $24.99
    $19.49 - $36.95
    $19.49 - $36.95
    $19.49
    Save up to 23% Save %
  • Save 33% Save %
    $39.99
    $39.99 - $39.99
    $39.99
    $26.95
    $26.95 - $26.95
    $26.95

    New York Fire Department "FDNY" Souvenir Teddy Bear (12x7") | NYC Souvenir

    Cuddly and bright eyed Stuffed Animal FDNY Firefighter teddy nyc souvenir. Surface Washable soft plush fur and build. Comes fitted in a full FDNY f...

    View full details
    $39.99
    $39.99 - $39.99
    $39.99
    $26.95
    $26.95 - $26.95
    $26.95
    Save 33% Save %
  • $12.49 - $24.95
    $12.49 - $24.95
    $12.49 - $24.95
    $12.49

    Stuffed Animal I Love NY T-Shirt Puppy (2 Colors)

    Cuddly and bright eyed Labrador Puppy Stuffed animal wearing an I Love NY T-Shirt. Surface Washable soft plush fur and build. Enjoy this New York t...

    View full details
    $12.49 - $24.95
    $12.49 - $24.95
    $12.49 - $24.95
    $12.49
  • $9.49 - $19.95
    $9.49 - $19.95
    $9.49 - $19.95
    $9.49

    Stuffed Labrador Retriever I Love NY Embroider (3 Sizes)

    Cuddly and bright eyed Labrador Puppy Stuffed animal wearing incorporating an I Love NY Embroider Stitching on the torso. Surface Washable soft plu...

    View full details
    $9.49 - $19.95
    $9.49 - $19.95
    $9.49 - $19.95
    $9.49
  • Sold out
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95

    Plush FDNY Firetruck | Kid's FDNY Collectible

    A fun piece of FDNY merch, for kids or to add to an FDNY collection! Well made soft leather substitute filled to capacity with non-allergenic stuff...

    View full details
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95
    Sold out
  • $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95

    Stuffed White Terrier Dog I Love NY Embroider (2 Sizes)

    Cuddly and bright eyed Terrier Puppy Stuffed animal incorporating an I Love NY Embroider Stitching on the torso. Surface Washable soft plush fur an...

    View full details
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95
  • Save up to 24% Save %
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95

    Plush NYPD Toy Car | NYPD Collectible

    A unique addition to our NYPD collection, the plush NYPD patrol car. Featuring a full blue anti-allergenic leather skin, lights & the NYPD logo...

    View full details
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99 - $16.99
    $12.99
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95
    Save up to 24% Save %
  • $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95

    Plush Stuffed Toy Taxi | Toy New York Taxi (2 Sizes)

    A great addition to our New York Toy Collection, this stuffed New York Toy Taxi comes in 2 Sizes! Featuring the full Yellow Cab Taxi look similar t...

    View full details
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95 - $12.95
    $9.95
  • $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95

    Stuffed Terrier Dog I Love NY Embroider (2 Sizes)

    Cuddly and bright eyed Terrier Puppy Stuffed animal incorporating an I Love NY Embroider Stitching on the torso. Surface Washable soft plush fur an...

    View full details
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95 - $19.49
    $14.95
  • $12.95 - $12.95
    $12.95
    $12.95 - $12.95
    $12.95

    Official New York Yankees Teddy Bear Toy | Yankees Baseball Shop

    A fantastic addition to our Yankees Baseball shop & an official piece of Yankees merch, this Yankees Teddy bear toy comes in a plush bean fille...

    View full details
    $12.95 - $12.95
    $12.95
    $12.95 - $12.95
    $12.95
  • $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95
    $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95

    Official NYPD Labrador Puppy Stuffed Animal

    A unique homage to the boys in blue, this stuffed animal comes in a Labrador puppy style with pearl white fur & wearing a thick NYPD Shirt. Whe...

    View full details
    $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95
    $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95
  • $29.95 - $29.95
    $29.95
    $29.95 - $29.95
    $29.95

    Large Stuffed New York Teddy Bear (17x11") | NYC Souvenir

    Cuddly and bright eyed Stuffed Animal teddy bear nyc souvenir incorporating an embroidered "New York" Logo on its torso. Surface Washable soft plus...

    View full details
    $29.95 - $29.95
    $29.95
    $29.95 - $29.95
    $29.95
  • $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95
    $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95

    Official FDNY Labrador Puppy Stuffed Animal

    A unique homage to New York's Bravest, this stuffed animal comes in a Labrador puppy style with pearl white fur & wearing an FDNY Shirt. Whethe...

    View full details
    $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95
    $11.95 - $11.95
    $11.95
  • Save 33% Save %
    $29.99
    $29.99 - $29.99
    $29.99
    $19.95
    $19.95 - $19.95
    $19.95

    I Love NY Husky Stuffed Animal Toy (10in)

    This high quality ultra plush Husky Stuffed animal is an exclusive addition to our I Love NY Gift Shop collection. A Licensed product by the NY Sta...

    View full details
    $29.99
    $29.99 - $29.99
    $29.99
    $19.95
    $19.95 - $19.95
    $19.95
    Save 33% Save %
  • Save 32% Save %
    $58.50
    $58.50 - $58.50
    $58.50
    $39.95
    $39.95 - $39.95
    $39.95

    I Heart New York Store Stuffed Animal Bundle | Ultra Plush Stuffed Animals (3-piece Set)

    The perfect gift from our I Heart New York Store, including our most high quality plush toys made by one of our best toy makers based here in NYC. ...

    View full details
    $58.50
    $58.50 - $58.50
    $58.50
    $39.95
    $39.95 - $39.95
    $39.95
    Save 32% Save %
  • Save 10% Save %
    $32.85
    $32.85 - $32.85
    $32.85
    $29.49
    $29.49 - $29.49
    $29.49

    I Love NY Store Bundle Toys | 3-piece New York Gift Box

    This I Love NY Store special features an I Love NY bundle featuring a 3-piece New York Gift Box of some of our most popular toys. Including a real ...

    View full details
    $32.85
    $32.85 - $32.85
    $32.85
    $29.49
    $29.49 - $29.49
    $29.49
    Save 10% Save %
  • Save 35% Save %
    $29.99
    $29.99 - $29.99
    $29.99
    $19.49
    $19.49 - $19.49
    $19.49

    I Love NY Cat Stuffed Animal Toy (10in)

    This high quality ultra plush Cat Stuffed animal is an exclusive addition to our I Love NY Gift Shop collection. A Licensed product by the NY State...

    View full details
    $29.99
    $29.99 - $29.99
    $29.99
    $19.49
    $19.49 - $19.49
    $19.49
    Save 35% Save %
  • $14.49 - $14.49
    $14.49
    $14.49 - $14.49
    $14.49

    Ultra Soft Plush I Love NY Teddy Bear Holding Heart | I Love NY Gifts

    Featuring an adorable ultra plush, soft fur I Love NY teddy bear holding a plush heart embroidered with the I Love NY logo in all white. The perfec...

    View full details
    $14.49 - $14.49
    $14.49
    $14.49 - $14.49
    $14.49
  • $11.95 - $19.49
    $11.95 - $19.49
    $11.95 - $19.49
    $11.95

    Heterochromatic Brown/White Terrier Dog Toy I Love NY Embroidered (3 Sizes)

    Cuddly and bright eyed Puppy Stuffed animal incorporating an I Love NY Embroider Stitching on the torso. Surface Washable soft plush fur and build....

    View full details
    $11.95 - $19.49
    $11.95 - $19.49
    $11.95 - $19.49
    $11.95
  • Save 13% Save %
    $39.99
    $39.99 - $39.99
    $39.99
    $34.95
    $34.95 - $34.95
    $34.95

    LARGE I Love NY Teddy Bear | New York Teddy Bear Toy

    Introducing our adorable and cuddly "I Love NY" teddy bear toy, perfect for kids and collectors alike. Standing at an impressive 17 inches tall, th...

    View full details
    $39.99
    $39.99 - $39.99
    $39.99
    $34.95
    $34.95 - $34.95
    $34.95
    Save 13% Save %